ENCINITAS — The Encinitas Environmental Commission recommended that the City Council pursue an ordinance to limit offshore oil and gas drilling by restricting new onshore facilities, a move intended to protect the coastline and reduce the environmental risks of drilling.
The commission voted unanimously Nov. 12 to recommend that city staff review options, including whether the council should adopt the ordinance or put it before voters.
California controls waters within 3 nautical miles of shore. Federal jurisdiction extends from there to the outer edge of the exclusive economic zone, 200 nautical miles offshore, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.
Commissioner J.P. Bruner said the proposed ordinance would focus on infrastructure within the city’s jurisdiction.
“Encinitas doesn’t have jurisdiction over the ocean,” Bruner said. “The goal of the ordinance is to prevent new onshore infrastructure, which currently Encinitas does not have an ordinance to prevent. So theoretically, if there were to be offshore drilling, Encinitas doesn’t have legal standing to prevent that.”
In California, 27 municipalities, including Oceanside and Carlsbad, have adopted ordinances banning onshore facilities for offshore drilling, forming what the advocacy group Save Our Shores calls the “blue wall.”
“Encinitas is a crucial gap in that blue wall,” given that “the federal threat of offshore drilling is growing,” Commissioner Katie Cramer said.
Encinitas adopted a resolution in 2018 opposing offshore drilling and fracking in response to a presidential executive order titled “Implementing an America-First Offshore Energy Strategy,” according to city documents.
On the first day of his second term, President Donald Trump signed an executive order titled “Unleashing American Energy.” The order argued that environmental regulations had driven up costs and hampered economic growth.
“America is blessed with an abundance of energy and natural resources that have historically powered our Nation’s economic prosperity,” the order reads. “In recent years, burdensome and ideologically motivated regulations have impeded the development of these resources, limited the generation of reliable and affordable electricity, reduced job creation, and inflicted high energy costs upon our citizens.”
In May, the U.S. Department of Commerce directed NOAA to review California’s coastal management program under the Coastal Zone Management Act, according to a department release.
“America must continue to lead in innovation, space exploration, and economic strength,” Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said in the release. “Obstructionist policies that delay critical national infrastructure in the name of environmental extremism are unacceptable. NOAA will conduct its reviews consistent with the plain text of the CZMA, ensuring states give proper weight to economic development and the nation’s priorities.”
Bruner said oil prices are set on a global market and that any short-term savings at the pump from increased offshore production would pale in comparison with the long-term environmental costs.
“The amount of oil that is offshore California that is not being tapped, especially oil off of the San Diego coast, is a drop in the bucket in the global scheme of things and will do absolutely nothing to our gas prices locally,” he said. “So there’s virtually no benefit to us in this region economically to have offshore oil drilling off of our coast. We essentially bear all of the weight and risk our livelihoods for profits elsewhere that won’t benefit our city.”
Cramer cited the 2010 Deepwater Horizon spill as an example of the risks of offshore drilling and said spills and leaks can harm fisheries, tourism and public health.
“Offshore oil and gas drilling can have really devastating consequences for coasts, wildlife and people, mainly through oil spills,” she said. “Oil drilling causes frequent spills and leaks that can cause long-term damage to coastal environments, economies and human health.
“It can result in really negative impacts to fisheries, closing fisheries, resulting in loss of food security, loss of livelihoods for the fisher people, loss of tourism revenue from beaches being closed and just an overall loss of quality of life for coastal residents.”
