SAN MARCOS — The Planning Commission recommended approval of a series of zoning and plan amendments to allow a 147-unit townhome development off Melrose Drive and Diamond Street, just north of San Elijo Road.
Known as Ascend, the project would include 88 three-story duplex townhouses and 59 detached townhouses on 16 acres of undeveloped land between existing residential neighborhoods in the city’s Questhaven/La Costa Meadows area.
An additional 7 acres would be set aside as a permanent open-space nature preserve. Each unit would have a two-car garage on the ground floor, with an additional 82 guest parking spaces throughout the new neighborhood.
Since the land is zoned for light industrial use, the Planning Commission was asked to recommend approval of seven resolutions related to the project. These included a site-specific plan, amendments to the city’s general plan, an environmental impact report and several rezoning proposals.
Roads in the development would be privately maintained through a homeowners association, according to Jason Greminger, a project manager with Consultants Collaborative who represented the developers at the meeting. The applicants were Diamond St. Industrial LLC & MDLV Investments LLC.
Both the staff report and the developer acknowledged that the project would have unmitigated traffic impacts along Melrose Drive, Rancho Santa Fe Road and San Elijo Road. The proposed permits would require the developer to install traffic signal coordination systems along Melrose Drive and at the intersection of Rancho Santa Fe and San Elijo roads.



During public comment, three speakers addressed the commission, all urging a no vote.
The first speaker, Lisa Bilotti, who lives nearby, expressed concern about fire evacuation times. The second speaker called the project a “recipe for disaster.” The third speaker, Amy Moss, who also said she lives near the proposed development, raised concerns about fire evacuation and general traffic safety.
Commissioner Christopher Carroll asked how traffic signal timing would be handled. Staff said the developer would have to run fiber-optic cables to connect the affected traffic lights.
Commissioner Mike Barnett said he thought it was a very good proposal but had philosophical concerns about rezoning parcels.
He said the traffic impacts can’t be overcome “because we don’t have enough employment opportunities in San Marcos. We can’t get more employment opportunities if we keep converting light industrial to residential.”
“I would prefer to see this project after the General Plan has been updated.”
Carroll pointed out that the parcel has been zoned for light industrial use for decades, but the developers have been unable to attract a light industrial tenant. He also questioned whether that zoning was appropriate given the relatively recent residential neighborhoods on either side of the parcel.
“Melrose is not a really good road for trucks to go down.”
He also pointed out that something would be built on the land and said he felt the proposal was “a very good use of the site.”
Carroll moved to recommend approval of the seven zoning and permitting proposals brought forward by staff. Commissioner Steve Kildoo seconded the motion, which passed with only Barnett opposed.
The proposal now heads to the City Council for consideration.
