The Coast News Group
Dr. Ed Siegel sings the Star Spangled Banner in G major at his home in Solana Beach. Photo by Shana Thompson
Cities Solana Beach Solana Beach Featured

Local singer advocate for lower-key national anthem


SOLANA BEACH — This July Fourth was set to be a banner day in Ed Siegel’s longtime crusade to have the national anthem sung in a lower octave.

The director of the Fort Collins Symphony Orchestra created a symphonic rendition of “The Star-Spangled Banner” in G major. It was scheduled to be performed with the longtime Solana Beach resident leading an estimated crowd of 20,000 people.

“This is the realization of a dream I’ve had since 2006,” he said before heading off to the Colorado city.

Unfortunately, with a threat of rain and lightning, the entire night’s performance was called off and the stage was cleared of instruments.

But the weather did little to dampen Siegel’s spirit.

“It was exciting,” he said. “We had a huge crowd and so I asked everyone if they wanted to sing the national anthem.

“I explained that not everyone can hit the high notes so we were going to sing it in a lower key,” he added. “A woman had a huge American flag so I called her up onstage. It was so special.”

The 78-year-old psychiatrist, wearing a patriotic pocket square and tie, then went down to a nearby lake where people were gathering to watch the fireworks. He asked the same question and got the same answer.

“I had servicemen and women and retired vets singing,” Siegel said. “I did that a couple of times. I was dressed for it. I was going to make the best of it.”

Siegel has long thought the national anthem, usually performed in B flat minor, was written in a key too high for most people to sing.

“We may be the only nation in the world whose citizens in general can’t sing their own national anthem,” he said. “We’re missing something here.”

His efforts to make the change earned him national attention with a 2004 story in “The New York Times Magazine” and later with a performance on “Today” in Rockefeller Plaza with Katie Couric.

Born and raised in Fort Collins, and a supporter of its symphony, Siegel asked music director Wes Kenney if he could work with the orchestra to perform the anthem in G major for the Independence Day show.

While his dream of hearing the lower-key, symphonic rendition played to a crowd was not realized, it wasn’t completely unfulfilled. Siegel was on hand the night before during rehearsal.

The symphony also played it a few nights later to a smaller crowd, although Siegel was back in California by that time.

Siegel has lived in Solana Beach for more than 40 years. On Aug. 6, 1987, about 30 people including the city’s first mayor, gathered at Fletcher Cove Community Center for his first singalong, which he started to promote community spirit.

It is the city’s oldest ongoing community event.

Siegel, who taught himself to play the piano by ear, also wrote the music for “Solana Beach Proud,” the city song.

1 comment

Ed Siegel, M.D. July 11, 2018 at 6:59 pm

Lynn Salsberg, RN wrote the words.

Comments are closed.