To the Editor:
I am grateful to Marcelo Garzo Montalvo for reminding us about the rich history of ethnic studies, now that it is expanding into elementary and high schools (“Do Ethnic Studies Right,” Nov. 29, 2024).
As a teacher in a public California campus, I am delighted by how the field has already shed light on cultures and communities that have seemed silent — even forcibly silenced — until now.
But I wonder about his insistence that ethnic studies remain tied to its political roots, and that somehow this represents the better way for schools to introduce it to adolescents and teenagers.
Don’t get me wrong: I’m all for fighting oppression, exposing underlying power structures and empowering students to be agents of change, all of which, apparently, drove the movement behind ethnic studies when it burst on the scenes in the 1960s.
But the author gives us no reason to think that the origin of the field has some kind of authoritative monopoly over how we should understand and develop it today.
Sociology, for example, began with a somewhat political purpose, partly in opposition to the approach that dominated economics at the time.
But plenty of its practitioners and students today — probably the vast majority — see sociology simply as a domain of empirical and theoretical research, both qualitative and quantitative, illuminating social life. I see no reason to think of this as failing to “do sociology right.”
The author similarly provides no evidence that young, pre-college Californians will learn more from ethnic studies if they see it as fundamentally agenda-driven.
In fact, if recent history is any guide, fields of study gain more ground — and fewer opponents — the less they are politicized.
Would the author prefer to do ethnic studies “right,” as he understands it, if that risked not doing it at all?
Jeff Helmreich is associate professor of philosophy at UC Irvine.
