The Coast News Group
Every year we wait, affordable homes disappear. The Coast News graphic
Every year we wait, affordable homes disappear. The Coast News graphic
Community CommentaryLettersOpinionOpinions

Commentary: We can’t afford to wait for affordable housing

Since 2019, California has allocated approximately $37 billion to housing and homelessness. Yet San Diego County’s homeless population has increased 21% over the same period.

After billions invested, are we solving homelessness or simply getting better at managing it?

We’ve invested in outreach, shelter, rental assistance, endless training and pathways to housing. But every pathway needs somewhere to lead, and we aren’t creating nearly enough homes people can afford.

With limited public resources, shouldn’t we be prioritizing investments that create and preserve permanent, deeply affordable housing? And shouldn’t the economics — cost, speed of delivery and generations of affordability — be central to those decisions?

I admit that asking can be scary. I run a small nonprofit in a large system where the institutions we question often control funding, convene partners and influence which ideas get heard. And frankly, they don’t always welcome questions. But if those doing the work won’t question the economics, who will?

Consider San Diego’s housing shortage. Under California’s Regional Housing Needs Allocation for 2021 through 2029, the city has targets for new homes across income levels. Through its 2025 reporting period, it had permitted just 9% of its very low-income target, 16% of its low-income target and 4% of its moderate-income target. Permitted, not completed.

Closing that gap requires more housing, faster. Yet most traditional affordable housing and permanent supportive housing projects depend on complicated capital stacks, take five to seven years and cost approximately $643,000 per home.

These projects are essential, especially for people needing intensive, ongoing services. But one expensive, slow development model cannot meet every need.

Our affordability crisis has contributed to economic homelessness among people whose primary barrier isn’t a need for intensive services but an inability to afford housing. Families, seniors and working people lose their homes because the math doesn’t work. The longer they remain unhoused, the more complicated and expensive their needs can become.

Different housing needs require different housing solutions.

That principle guides Rise Up Residential, a nonprofit applying proven private-sector development practices to address economic homelessness by creating permanent affordable housing faster and at lower cost.

In 2023, our J Street Affordable Housing Project received an initial public investment to demonstrate this approach — acquire residential property, preserve existing homes, add homes through light-touch infill and use the value created to sustain affordability.

At a neighborhood scale, J Street will preserve four homes and create 12 more, including family housing and self-contained efficiency homes. That’s 16 permanent homes serving up to 43 people at a time.

All 16 will be deed-restricted for 55 years at 50% of area median income, with rents modeled around 30% of area median income. Delivery takes approximately 18 months at roughly $250,000 per home. Once stabilized, the property is designed to operate without ongoing public subsidy.

One-time capital investment. Five generations of affordability.

Imagine if we’d spent the past three years replicating and refining this approach. How many buildings could we have preserved, how many properties could we have expanded and how many people could we have housed?

Twelve affordable units have already been lost on J Street’s block alone. Every year we wait, the shortage grows.

The private real estate sector evaluates investments by cost, schedule, operating performance and long-term value. When results fall short, we question the strategy. With $37 billion allocated statewide while San Diego County’s homeless count rose 21%, shouldn’t leadership face serious questions about strategy, accountability and return on investment?

California has distributed billions through successive rounds of homelessness funding. But how much has actually created or preserved permanent affordable housing? How much has gone to programs, administration and services? These efforts have a role, but they cannot replace the permanent housing needed to end homelessness.

This isn’t about favoring one model. It’s about making every dollar count.

San Diego needs a housing portfolio that includes preservation, accessory dwelling units, adaptive reuse, neighborhood-scale infill, larger affordable developments and permanent supportive housing. Use service-intensive housing where needed and simpler, lower-cost homes where affordability is the primary barrier. When a model delivers lasting affordability faster and for less, replicate it.

We cannot keep creating pathways out of homelessness without building the destination.

Permanent housing isn’t separate from the homelessness response. It is the exit. And if we’re serious about ending homelessness, the economics have to matter.

Amanda Noeldechen is the executive director of Rise Up Residential.

Leave a Comment