The Coast News Group
Light Church has entered escrow to buy the property that includes La Paloma Theater in Encinitas, where the church holds weekly services. File photo/The Coast News
Light Church has entered escrow to buy the property that includes La Paloma Theater in Encinitas, where the church holds weekly services. File photo/The Coast News
Arts & EntertainmentCitiesEncinitasEncinitas Featured

Church enters escrow to buy, preserve La Paloma Theater in Encinitas

ENCINITAS — A local church that has held weekly services at La Paloma Theater for years has entered escrow to buy the historic property, which church leaders say they hope to preserve.

Benji Horning, lead pastor of Light Church, told The Coast News that preserving the theater’s legacy would be the church’s priority if the purchase goes through.

“Our core belief is not just our belief in God, but it’s our love of neighbor,” Horning said. “And so we see this as a way just to love our neighbor and neighborhood. We know how much it is loved.”

The church entered escrow Oct. 26 to buy the property, which includes La Paloma and surrounding businesses, according to media reports.

Horning told The Coast News he expects the sale to close in late January or early February 2027 if all goes smoothly.

“We’re still very much in the early phases,” Horning said. “So obviously lots of inspections and reports and meetings with the city and things like that just for us to understand what this all entails.

“Our main and most urgent goal is just the restoration of La Paloma … We want to make sure the roof does not cave in.”

Light Church began in 2018 in the living room of Benji and Jennifer Horning in Encinitas. Jennifer Horning serves as the church’s co-pastor and creative director.

The church began renting a chapel on Third Street in Encinitas and later bought it. At the time, Water’s Edge Church held regular Sunday services at La Paloma.

Benji Horning said pandemic restrictions and a growing congregation led Light Church to rethink where it met. The church struck a deal with Water’s Edge in 2021.

“We actually swapped,” he said. “We started meeting at La Paloma, and they started meeting in our chapel in the morning. We just needed more space, but on top of that, I mean, La Paloma is just this beautiful part of our city.

“Even before we had started planting the church, we had this dream, like, ‘how cool it would be if we were able to be in that space that is so beloved and so historic, so beautiful.’

“And so for us to be able to get in there honestly felt like a dream come true. We’ve been there for five years now. It’s been awesome.”

‘The gift’

With the purchase still in its early stages, Benji Horning said it was too soon to say what arrangements the church might make with La Paloma or the other businesses.

He said the church has developed a close relationship with Allen Largent, La Paloma’s president and operator, over years of renting the theater for Sunday services.

“What I’ve told him is, ‘hey, we’d love to have that conversation with you when it’s time to have a conversation with you,” Horning said. “We haven’t told him he’s out. We haven’t told him he’s in. We’re just like, ‘hey, right now, you are renting to us.’

“We’re so grateful. And we have every intention to keep running this as a venue in a theater. And so when the time comes, or if the time comes, for us to start looking at tenants and leases and things like that, then he’ll obviously be the first person we talk to. There’s so much we don’t know at this point. But we love Allen a lot, and we’re grateful for him.”

Largent did not immediately respond to text messages from The Coast News seeking comment.

Horning said the church intends to honor existing leases for other businesses on the block, including Sago.

The Hornings stressed the importance of keeping La Paloma as a community venue for film premieres, surf documentary festivals, concerts and other live events. Jennifer Horning noted that Benji once played in a screamo punk band.

“The music scene is very important to us,” she said.

Benji Horning said the church has been in touch with city officials and Irene Pyun, executive director of Encinitas 101 MainStreet, as it looks into what it would take to preserve the theater.

La Paloma is not listed in the National Park Service’s National Register of Historic Places or among California Historical Landmarks, according to the state and federal databases.

Pyun said a 2016 effort to secure formal historic recognition for the theater included a report commissioned from Dudek. The effort fell through, she said.

Pyun said Encinitas 101 and Light Church share a goal of renewing that effort.

“Historic preservation is their number one, as it is ours,” she said. “They’re really going to pour a lot of money into the theater.”

Benji Horning said the church would consider paying to secure historic designation once the building is structurally sound.

“If we can get this thing safe, then we essentially said, ‘we as a church will explore and potentially even fund it becoming a historical site,’” he said. “I can’t say we’re going to do that for sure yet, because we just don’t know enough yet. But, we would love to do that if that makes sense.”

The Hornings said their first priority is to make sure the theater is structurally sound as part of a restoration that preserves its character.

“Rather than modernize it, how do we restore the beautiful historicity of it … to its original glory?” Benji said. “It’s still called La Paloma Theater, I mean, that’s the thing. This isn’t like a brand move.”

“You probably won’t even see a Light Church sign anywhere,” Jennifer said. “Our plan was not to be this loud, big change. It was to be this subtle, beautiful restoration.”

She said the project fits with other work the church has taken on, including helping 8,000 families avoid eviction during the COVID-19 pandemic, building a school for asylum-seekers in Mexico and helping Ukrainian orphanages evacuate at the outset of the war with Russia.

“We’re not an insulated community that’s sitting here caring about ourselves. The proof is in the pudding in that we deeply want to and have cared for people,” Jennifer said. “I wear Encinitas on my heart.”

She said that “at the end of the day, we want people at some point to experience the gift” of La Paloma at some point.

Leave a Comment