Area golfers waiting for improvements to Goat Hill

Area golfers waiting for improvements to Goat Hill
Avid golfer Tom Fukuhara of Oceanside, hits the ball off the driving range. Fukuhara describes Goat Hill a fun course with a nice breeze. Photo by Promise Yee

OCEANSIDE — Golf regulars at the Center City Golf Course, locally known as Goat Hill, are wondering when, if ever, improvements to the municipal golf course will be made. 

City Council voted to begin negotiations with the Ashworth group in August 2012, but a management agreement between Ashworth and the city has not been reached.

Doug Eddow, city real estate manager, said since negotiations are ongoing he cannot discuss points that still need to be ironed out.

Last August Goat Hill Partners, which is part of the Ashworth group, proposed the land be kept as a golf course and redesigned by golf architect Tom Doak. Improvements would include a new clubhouse, a two-story restaurant, a six-hole kids course, a community vegetable garden and a botanical garden.

“Great cities in the world don’t turn over all their green space and turn them into concrete,” John Ashworth, of Goat Hill Partners, said. “It can be a destination location to come play.”

Since accepting the proposal from Ashworth, no agreement has been finalized. Speculators think delays may have to do with the cost of getting water to the site.

Goat Hill is an executive level 18-hole golf course that is presently watered with expensive potable water. The ill design of the course, which opened in 1953, adds to the challenge to keep it green. The course design causes water to run off the hills and not stay there.

“The terrain of Goat Hill is rugged and very hilly,” Jim Bellows, owner of Bellows Golf Management that currently manages the golf course, said. “There are a lot of rocks and it’s very difficult to grow grass in the shape of the hills.”

Additionally the size of the municipal course will always limit fees that can be charged to play. Development limitations coupled with the present cost of water have made the golf course unprofitable.

The potential for golf professional Ashworth to manage the course, bring in a top course designer, and make Goat Hill a destination golf course is a great opportunity for the city.

City staff and golfers are hoping the negotiation goes through.

Goat Hill is already a beloved course by many area golfers. Its uniqueness is what draws local golfers and a handful of professional players to the course.

The course is steep and hilly. Golfers say you never play the same game twice. Disc golfers also use the course.

Due to ongoing negotiations, the recent recession, and lack of revenues, the city has directed Bellows Golf Management to give the course minimal maintenance.

The thought is that Ashworth will redesign the course once negotiations are finalized.

In the meantime, the course receives minimum city investment in water and maintaining golf carts.

Staff at the golf course said there has been a significant drop in players over the past two years due to the golf course’s declining condition and lack of working golf carts, which are essential for senior golfers to play the very hilly course.

Last fiscal year 22,300 players used the golf course. This year only 7,450 players have used the course since July.

Currently there is no definite timeline for negotiations with Ashworth to be finalized.

Eddow said the city is still open to other development ideas until an agreement is finalized, but is not actively negotiating with other parties.

“We’re hammering out small details,” Eddow said. “The Ashworth group likes the golf course. They want to make sure they look at everything. Overall they’re jumping into a long-term agreement and want to make the right decision.”

City staff said they do not know of any other agreements that are being considered.

“We’re close to the end, but haven’t selected them (Ashworth group),” Curtis Jackson, city property agent said.


Filed Under: Featured


RSSComments (1)

Leave a Reply | Trackback URL

  1. Speaking on behalf of the Ashworth Group, as one of the members and creators of this project, I would say to anyone reading this that we have been ready to sign the papers since day one. We have been waiting everyday for nearly a year now. We have a plan, we have investors, and we have the world’s greatest course architect (Tom Doak) behind us. We were days away from the set signing date in the first week of December when the City informed us that they were putting the project on hold for 90 days. This means that Goat Hill sits with an expired lease for 90 days. We were not given reason, except to say that they are looking into another plan that they like a lot, but can’t tell us about it. This is interesting because it is done regarding public land… behind closed doors… with a group that did not have to meet or participate in the public proposal (RFP) we all were required to do. Please understand that the statistics here are misleading. The numbers are down because there is no advertising for goat hill. There is no branding. There is hardly any care left. It is my opinion that this is all manufactured to help sway public consent to pave goat hill… something the city managers would love to do. Our proposal turns Goat Hill into a destination landmark for Oceanside. It puts it into a national spectrum for golf. It creates a model for muni courses around the country. It develops the land into a real public park. Oceanside’s own Central Park. The course would include Community gardens, a sculpture park, walking trails to ocean views, a public amphitheater, and we would close the course on certain days to allow for free public use. Please do not listen to those that say there isn’t enough water, the terrain is rocky, golf is in decline… These are the voices of those who stand to profit from other avenues. We can make this place everything it should be. If anyone has any questions, please email me at . Thank you.

Leave a Reply

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a Gravatar.