Rancho Santa Fe Review CEO threatens to sue publisher of Rancho Santa Fe News and The Coast News

RANCHO SANTA FE — In a David versus Goliath standoff, the Rancho Santa Fe News is facing the threat of a lawsuit by Anthony Allegretti, president and CEO of MainStreet Communications, which publishes 17 newspapers including the Rancho Santa Fe Review.
The proposed charge is that the Rancho Santa Fe News’ advertising rates are driving the financially backed “Review” out of business, or at least hurting its profits.
On the David side the “News” is owned by independent publisher Jim Kydd and is one of two publications of The Coast News Group. The bimonthly News distributes on demand and mails 10,000 copies to Rancho Santa Fe, Santaluz and the Rancho Pacifica areas.
Kydd said the News is part of a tightknit operation that carefully balances its profits and overhead costs to operate. The paper has no debt service or investment bankers to pay off. Kydd said a skeleton staff and shared operating costs with The Coast News allows the paper to have a minimum overhead.
Kydd said the News could not remain in operation if it was under-pricing its advertisements. He added that they have recently closed papers in Vista, San Marcos and Carmel Valley because they were not profitable.
On the Goliath side, the Review is owned and published by MainStreet Communications, a subsidiary of MainStreet Media Group. It is one of 17 newspapers that MainStreet Communications publishes.
Other area newspapers owned by MainStreet Communications include, in addition to the Review, the Carmel Valley News, the Del Mar Times, the Solana Beach Sun, the La Jolla Light, the Poway News-Chieftain, the Rancho Bernardo News-Journal and the Ramona Sentinel. MainStreet Media Group also owns a group of newspapers in Northern and Central California. MainStreet’s corporate offices are in Gilroy, Calif.
Kydd said the Review has much higher operating costs including editorial salaries as well as financial backers to pay.
Brookside Capital Partners Management works as the investment manager for MainStreet Communications. Managing Director Don Hawks said as a matter of company policy he has no comment on Allegretti’s actions.
Hawks was asked if he was aware of the certified letters Allegretti sent to the News. “I’m not going to comment on those,” Hawks said.
Housatonic Partners is another investment manager for MainStreet Communications and owns 36 percent of the company.
Joe Niehaus, general partner for Housatonic Partners, would not comment on the registered letters sent to The Coast News Group or the proposed lawsuit. “I’m not going to address any of that,” Niehaus said.
Allegretti claims in certified letters that the News caused the Review to lose at least $300,000 in 2010. He further threatened to sue for $900,000 plus attorney fees he estimates at $2 million, if the News advertising rates are not “adjusted” and increased.
“The law Allegretti is quoting is to protect the little guy,” Kydd said. “I don’t have the money to outlast him and his investment bankers and he knows it. He’s the predator.”
Kydd does not know what prices Allegretti charges for advertising. Likewise, he said Allegretti does not have access to the News’ records of pricing or operating costs on which his allegation is based.
Several area attorneys, all of whom declined to be quoted, were asked for their opinions on the charges. All agreed that it is unlikely that the suit will go to court due to the lack of evidence and the disparity in size between the two publishing companies. They added that it is difficult for a large newspaper group to claim that it was hurt by the rates of a smaller paper.
“No one can tell you what price you have to sell at,” one of the attorneys said. He went on to say that any attempt to limit competition is restraint of trade.
Allegretti has reportedly made similar threats to other small papers in San Diego County. While publishers did not want to be quoted directly, some say they have heard around the publishing community that Allegretti recently sent a similar letter to another San Diego County newspaper. He threatened to sue the paper and then offered to buy the paper at a “lowball” price.
The publisher of that paper, who did not want to be quoted, said they consider Allegretti’s proposed lawsuit a bluff, but are fearful that if Allegretti follows through they will not be able to weather the possible court costs, that could run in the millions, to show that there is no merit to the charges.
MainStreet Communications Chief Operating Officer Steve Staloch said he is not aware of Allegretti’s offer to buy any paper at this time. “We’re always interested in acquisitions that make sense, strategic acquisitions,” Staloch said.
When asked about the proposed lawsuits Staloch had no comment. “This is not a news story,” Staloch said.
If Allegretti pursues the lawsuits, his claims could damage the livelihood of two local newspapers.
One longtime local publisher said that instead of basing competition on readership and compelling news columns, Allegretti is basically saying “play ball with me or I’ll spend you into submission.”
“He has the fear factor going for him,” Kydd said. “His package of certified letters is nothing but a scare tactic and also smacks of price collusion.”
Allegretti said he would not speak directly about any proposed lawsuit and did not confirm that that his company is losing money.
“A company can be making money,” Allegretti said. “It’s nothing to do with whether you’re doing well or whether you’re doing poorly. It has to do with the other business. The law says you can’t sell anything below cost.”
Kydd said the charges do not make sense because the News runs a balanced budget with all fully loaded costs, including building rental, utilities and sales commissions.
Kydd and others see the situation as Allegretti trying to leverage his size and multiple publications to eliminate competition.
“It just smells,” one attorney said.
Allegretti insists size does not matter. “The law is meant for all California companies,” Allegretti said. “It’s nothing to do with the size of a company.”
“This is a direct attack against all Rancho Santa Fe advertisers present and future,” Kydd said. “If I were to cave in, he would have no competition in the marketplace.”
Allegretti may be opening up himself and his company for a lawsuit.
“I’m considering suing him for threatening me and suggesting price fixing,” Kydd said. “I think what he’s doing is terribly wrong.”

Click here to download a ZIP file of all the documents in this story

Get Jim Kydd’s side of the story in his Op Ed:

Op Ed: Publisher says Review seeks to control ad prices in Rancho Santa Fe
by Jim Kydd, Publisher Coast News Group

I rarely get on the pulpit. It takes something really, really wrong to get me going.
Enter Anthony Allegretti, the bully.
He is the CEO of the Rancho Santa Fe Review.
He is bullying me to “fix” my advertising prices to be as high as his are.
This is a direct attack against all Rancho Santa Fe advertisers — present and future. If I were to cave in, he would have no competition in the marketplace.
Here’s what he’s doing.
Last Friday I received a package of documents from Allegretti, who publishes numerous publications here in San Diego and elsewhere.
He is a big-time publisher compared to me and is backed by well-funded investment bankers. We’re talking billions here.
This “nice” package I received from Allegretti dated Feb. 14 — my valentine, I guess — contained a threat to sue me and the Rancho Santa Fe News for a violation of the California Fair Practice Act and various violations of other antitrust legislation.
He alleged I was charging too little for my ads in 2010, thereby causing him to lose money. He said that if I didn’t raise my rates he would sue me for $900,000 (three times his lost revenue) and my legal fees would be around $2 million.
That is his position.
That is also a threat.
I used to have five newspapers. I closed three of them and one office because they weren’t profitable.
If the Rancho Santa Fe News’ low ad rates were causing me to lose money, as his threatened lawsuit implies, why would I keep publishing it?
His “package” is nothing but a scare tactic and also smacks of price collusion. If I were to charge what he wants me to charge for advertising, what happens to “fair competition in the marketplace?” All advertisers will be forced to pay the same rate, which will be set by Allegretti.
I run a tight business and don’t have any debt service or investment bankers to pay off. Allegretti does, so maybe that’s why he has to charge more for his ads.
Maybe he just wants no competition so he can price “gouge.”
In the end, it will be the advertiser that will be hurt.
My only reason for writing this editorial is to expose Allegretti as a mean-spirited scoundrel of a businessman and to warn current and prospective advertisers of his tactics.
I just recently learned that Allegretti served the same Valentine’s Day package to a fellow publisher who competes with Allegretti in La Jolla.
This time he got the desired reaction. Already struggling with the economy, this publisher became very upset that he could face the possible loss of hundreds of thousands of dollars and the cost of $2 million in legal fees.
Here comes the good part.
Allegretti meets with this publisher and offers to buy the competing paper for a fraction of its value or says he will sue.
If you ask me, that is also an unfair business practice and just plain mean.
If he buys it, he will probably close it, creating a price fixing situation much the same as he is trying to do in Rancho Santa Fe. La Jolla advertisers will suffer.
If you currently advertise with the Review, I just want you to know where your money is going — to Allegretti and his investment bankers.
Perhaps when your contract is up with the Review, you might want to give us a call.
Obviously we charge less. We also give more.
In addition to being distributed everywhere the Review is, the Rancho Santa Fe News is mailman-delivered to 1,100 homes in the Santaluz area and 500 homes in the Rancho Pacifica area. The Review leaves these areas out of their circulation.
I am not going to allow Allegretti and the Review to scare me into raising my ad prices.
I’ve consulted a friend in the San Diego District Attorney’s office. I was advised to have my lawyer send a warning to Allegretti and his backers that they should cease any further action. Perhaps they aren’t smart enough to know that what they’re doing is illegal, so my lawyer is currently drafting a letter to them explaining the law.
They are leaving themselves open to some very serious legal ramifications and all advertisers will suffer.

Share

Filed Under: Lead StoryNewsRancho Santa Fe Lead StoryRancho Santa Fe NewsThe Coast News

Tags:

RSSComments (10)

Leave a Reply | Trackback URL

  1. Peter Desmond says:

    What ever happened to the Free Market system??? Makes me even more likely to place an ad w/ The Coast News!

  2. Pro Trees says:

    I never liked the fact that The "Rancho Santa Fe Review" is owned by some east coast corparation.
    Mainstreet Media?
    The Rancho Review is a rip off anyway.
    Allegretti should go home and stop wasting time suing people! Keep it local if you can!

  3. Dedicated Reader says:

    It’s a shame that Main Street Media has to resort to threats against Rancho Santa Fe News and the La Jolla publisher. Their negative approach to business only adds to what’s wrong with large business! I applaud Jim Kydd for standing tall and exposing them for what they really are- just another corporation trying to make as much money as possible. Shame on them!

  4. www.ahharsfnews.com says:

    "If you currently advertise with the Review, I just want you to know where your money is going — to (Gilroy owner) Allegretti and his investment bankers.
    Housatonic Partners is another investment manager for MainStreet Communications and owns 36 percent of the company…Allegretti claims in certified letters that the News caused the Review to lose at least $300,000 in 2010.
    He further threatened to sue for $900,000 plus attorney fees he estimates at $2 million, if the News advertising rates are not “adjusted” and increased."
    – Jim Kydd, Coast News publisher
    DO YOU WANT YOUR ADS BEING PART OF THIS GREEDY DISPUTE BETWEEN TWO NON-LOCAL OVERBLOWN OWNERS OR GO TO THE PROFESSIONAL JOURNALISM WEBSITE DRAWING MORE PEOPLE PER DAY THAN THEY DO COMBINED IN A MONTH? WE ARE THE REAL DEAL FOR THE COMMUNITY AND FOR YOU IN MAXIMIZING AD DOLLARS AND KEEPING YOUR LOCAL FOCUS.
    —————————————————————
    It’s YOUR time to benefit from advertising at the most effective community journalism site in the nation
    Ah-Ha Rancho Santa Fe News
    http://www.AhHaRSFNews.com

    ABOUT US:
    - Born out of a desire to bring daily journalism coverage to Rancho Santa Fe, and surrounding communities, Ah-Ha Rancho Santa Fe News was launched in June 2010.
    - Ah-Ha RSF News is one of the top community journalism sites in the nation and is the top in per capita page views.
    - Founder, Dan Weisman, is a fellow at Knight Digital Media Center, University of Southern California, Annenberg School for Communication and Journalism, where he, and leading online experts, fine-tuned the groundbreaking Ah-Ha RSF News model.
    • The communities in our coverage area are highly sought after by advertisers because of their appealing age and income demographics. The majority of our readers are college educated, professionals and have a greater amount of disposable income than other areas reached by the big dailies.
    • Ah-Ha RSF News is more regularly read because our news coverage focuses on the events that have particular interest to our communities – the events that happen across the street, and in their own back yard.
    BENEFITS OF ONLINE ADVERTISING
    - Online advertising is one step ahead over others, as more people are going online for their news than ever before.
    - The primary benefit of online advertising over offline is that online advertising offers maximum exposure for a minimal cost. Everyone who visits Ah-Ha RSF News will see your ad, including local, regional, national, and global. This is an exceptional advantage to many businesses.
    
- Online advertising has no time limitations and is viewed day and night throughout the globe.
    - Online advertising is much more cost-effective, is targeted to your audience, and has much higher viewership than advertising in a regional newspaper.
    - As more people rely on computers there is a change in trend, shifting from print to online news. It is an “immediate medium”.
    
- By using Google Analytics, we are able to keep an eye on the performance of advertising campaign by how many page views we receive, and how many “clicks” your specific ad gets. This is impossible in other types of media. This data enables you to modify your campaign to achieve maximum effectiveness thus targeting potential customers.
    ADVERTISE WITH US!
    Ah-Ha Rancho Santa Fe News averages 5,500 daily page views, many days reaching 8,000 views, and that number is growing all the time. The site had 10,800 page hits, 6,200 user sessions on March 1.
    Email us at 92067freepress@gmail.com for more details.

  5. Viewfinder says:

    Anyone else wonder ‘Why’ The Coast News cannot find a writer/columnist to take the place of the late Bob Nanninga on Page 4?
    Aside from Nanninga being one-of-a-kind, clearly, in a local society of tens of thousands of writers/journalists and poets in North County Coastal San Diego, even the most starving artists have been warned by their brethren that the Kydds are completely untrustworthy.
    How else can one explain a ‘local’ paper than seems incapable of finding and publishing a new voice?
    NOTE: Never give a credit card number to a salesperson from any local weekly periodical…EVER.
    The Kydd’s current attempt to ‘cry (foul) fowl’ is absolutely hysterical. If it wasn’t for legal advertising requiring publication, this father/son publishing act would have been relegated to the bottom of local bird cages only, where they clearly belong.

  6. Sydney LeBlanc says:

    I applaud Jim Kydd and the Coast News for being unafraid to take a stand and defend himself and the newspaper against such an obvious bully. I have been in the publication business for 35 years and have only seen this kind of blatant coercion twice, and both times the bullies lost. I have been a loyal Coast News reader when it began as The Beach News more than 20 years ago. I also know many of the past and current advertisers, who will all stand behind Jim Kydd’s business ethics. I have also known the Kydd family for more than 20 years. I have never seen Jim or Chris practice anything other than strict business and personal ethics in any of their dealings with businesses and individuals on any level. As a matter of fact, I would count Jim and Chris among the top 5 people I know who possess a high degree of integrity, values, morals, and kindness and compassion. Yes, I said kindness and compassion. Don’t believe me? Just ask his staff, his friends, his neighbors, his advertisers, and others in the community. And I don’t mean the disgruntled folks like "Viewfinder" who posted a very mean-spirited and untrue posting below. What’s the matter Viewfinder….afraid to post your real name? Sour grapes? And just how do you know they "can’t" find a replacement for their friend, the late BoB Nanninga? Maybe they don’t WANT to. Maybe Bob was irreplaceable!!! Maybe not replacing Bob is a testimony to friendship. But I guess your little pea-brain didn’t think about that. What you are spewing is hateful and uncalled for. Plus you need to get your facts in line before you post something untrue. What are you? 12 years old? Or just a shill for Allegretti? Oh, that’s it. A shill. Allegretti should rename his business Mean Street Media. He and his investor group should be ashamed of themselves for their behavior. They have no idea of fair play, nor do they care. The free market system is of no use to them. But they can parade their big time corporate lawyers in to threaten to shut down every competitor they don’t like or who is "better" than their own enterprise. Good luck Allegretti. Ethics and integrity win over coercion and bullying every time. Weasels never win in the long run.

  7. Mandy Barre says:

    You should look at this as an opportunity to get attorneys fees based on a lack of Merit by this guy. Threats against free speech and commerce will go nowhere but with attorneys fees and damages into the Kydd pocket.

  8. Swept Up says:

    Joel Osteen certainly has aged lately.

  9. sales 4 weekly papr says:

    yea-im a salesperson from a weekly periodical…and this is directed towards jackass..yes you "viewfinder"…."dont ever give your credit card # to a salesperson for a weekly periodical"…r you serious? you are obviously someone from some daily rag or some other wanna be bad ass..I take offense to that, because I take credit cards all week, and have never done anything unethical nor do i support anyone who would do anything unethical..gee lets see how many weekly periodicals there are…ok and how many advertisers are there in each? ok now lets see, if im an advertiser and I want to place an ad, what the F%$&* do you expect me to pay with?…seashells?..oh ok ill just fill out and mail in a check, cuz i totally have time for that….consumers and businesses are protected by fraud protection laws/insurance…what the hell am i gonna do with someones credit card # anyways?…not to mention advertisers sign contracts…if you sign a contract and dont read it then youre gonna try and argue over it, maybe you should read something before you sign it..i cant speak for every weekly out there, but I know here we stick to a system and it works pretty well..occasionally youre gonna have some moron blowhard who didnt actually read the agreement before he signed it and its then gonna piss and moan cuz he thinks he got overcharged 32$..When really, he just hates his life and feels it necessary to try and make someone else suffer with him..

  10. hugh jielder says:

    Man, every time I see that picture of Allegrossy I get mad.He just looks like a smarmy little sh*t weasel

Leave a Reply




If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a Gravatar.